Aftershave

9 clues
Men's lotion
Brut, for one
Cologne's cousin
Witch hazel, e.g.
Occasional stinger
Witch hazel or bay rum
It hurts when you rub it in
Item in a man's medicine chest
It's rubbed in following razor use
Similar answers:
Acloseshaveaway
After
After125
After4odaysrain
Aftera
Afterafashion
Afterafterparty
Afteragreatchef
Afterall
Afterallah
Afterallissaid
Afteraskort
Afterasort
Afteratime
Afterawhile
Afterbeingasked
Afterbody
Afterburner
Afterc
Aftercare