Druthers

3 clues
Preference
First choice
Preference, so to speak
Similar answers:
Aboveallothers
Achers
Acutaboveothers
Adoptivefathers
Allstarcatchers
Amesbrothers
Amherst
Amhersthamster
Amothers
Andhers
Andothers
Andsignsherselfmotherof
Anothers
Anotherserving
Anotherstakeout
Anotherstormydayifear
Anthers
Applepolishers
Archers
Archersbow