| Suspect |
| Dubious |
| Suspicious |
| 'Unlikely!' |
| Questionable |
| Unconvincing |
| Not quite right |
| Hard to swallow |
| A bit suspicious |
| Pretty suspicious |
| ''Unbelievable!'' |
| Arousing suspicion |
| A bit questionable |
| Suspicious at sea? |
| Arousing skepticism |
| Suspicious, informally |
| Dubious — piscatorial |
| Like some hole-in-one claims |
| What this puzzle is, apparently |
| Like a tale of "the one that got away |