Intheory

5 clues
On paper
Supposedly
Hypothetically
Possibly, but unlikely
Hypothetically: 2 wds.
Similar answers:
Abenchinthepark
Abirdinthehand
Abirdinthesand
Absinth
Absinthe
Absintheminded
Acafeinthecrowd
Aceinthehole
Aceinthehull
Acryinthedark
Actintheplaceof
Adayinthe
Adayinthelife
Adayintheussr
Adeathinthe
Adivinityinthat
Adjointheclub
Adoginthemanger
Adroopinthebucket
Adropintheocean