| A missing pencil may be behind one |
| Creepy pencil-and-paper "game" popularized in 2015 via YouTube and Twitter (and basis of the theme answers) |
| Pencil pusher |
| Kid's pencil puzzle |
| Utensils on pencils |
| Used charcoal pencils, say |
| Pencil remnants |
| Convenient pencil perches |
| Blotter/pencil-cup ensemble |
| Much-sharpened pencils |
| Passes time with a pencil |
| Pencil pushers |
| Wax pencils |
| A golf pencil doesn't have one |
| A golf pencil rarely has one |
| Blue-penciled symbol |
| Wielders of blue pencils (Abbr.) |
| Blue-pencil wielders |
| Blue-pencil |
| Ends of pencils. |
| Pencil rubbers |
| Diminutive pencil |
| Red-pencils |
| Blue-pencils. |
| Blue-pencil again |
| Edited 1977 horror film about both ends of a pencil? |
| Worn-down pencils |
| A pencil, compared to a pen |
| Huge pencil add-on? |
| Pencil ends |