| Odd |
| Weird |
| Scary |
| Alien |
| Uneasy |
| Freaky |
| Spooky |
| Arcane |
| Bizarre |
| Ghostly |
| Surreal |
| Uncanny |
| Poe-ish |
| Haunted |
| Peculiar |
| Chilling |
| Very odd |
| Fearsome |
| Spectral |
| Ghoulish |
| Eldritch |
| Spookish |
| Freakish |
| Haunting |
| Unworldly |
| Ghostlike |
| Unearthly |
| Unnatural |
| Creepy -- |
| À la Poe |
| Kinglike? |
| Way weird |
| Fucked up |
| Poe-esque |
| Unnerving |
| Mysterious |
| A la King? |
| Unsettling |
| -- macabre |
| Like "Lost |
| Phantasmal |
| Paranormal |
| Frightening |
| Not natural |
| Creeptastic |
| Goosebump-y |
| Like "Alien |
| Oddly scary |
| Goose-pimply |
| Very strange |
| Otherworldly |
| Strange ____ |
| Really weird |
| Hair-raising |
| Hitchcockian |
| A bit spooky |
| Haunted, say |
| Not just odd |
| Halloweenish |
| Lovecraftian |
| ___ Like It |
| Supernatural |
| Creepy-crawly |
| Fear-inducing |
| Bone-chilling |
| More chilling |
| Inducing fear |
| Spinetingling |
| ____, Indiana |
| Sort of scary |
| Unexplainable |
| Chill-causing |
| Halloweenlike |
| Really creepy |
| Very peculiar |
| Really spooky |
| More than odd |
| Preternatural |
| Inspiring fear |
| Spine-tingling |
| Mighty strange |
| Spine-chilling |
| Like a séance |
| Blood chilling |
| Fear-inspiring |
| Hackle-raising |
| Halloween-like |
| Kind of creepy |
| Like "The Ring |
| Like déjà vu |
| Like Poe works |
| Oct. 31 canal? |
| Oddly familiar |
| Other-worldly? |
| Causing chills |
| Like Psycho |
| Shiver-causing |
| Weirdly spooky |
| Like some fogs |
| Spookily weird |
| Beyond unusual |
| Like Poe tales |
| Really strange |
| Chill-inducing |
| Causing fright |
| Shiver-inducing |
| Not quite right |
| Like a Poe tale |
| Apt to frighten |
| Awfully strange |
| Far from normal |
| Like "The Raven |
| Like a funhouse |
| Like Poe pieces |
| Likely to spook |
| Maumee Bay lake |
| Not explainable |
| Pretty peculiar |
| Scarily strange |
| Strangely scary |
| Unsettling, say |
| Very odd indeed |
| Willies-causing |
| Causing shivers |
| Like "Halloween |
| Like Poe's work |
| Paranormal, say |
| Creeps-inducing |
| Weirdly strange |
| Weird and scary |
| Hard to explain |
| Kind of silence |
| Ghastly strange |
| Extraterrestrial |
| Willies-inducing |
| Creeping you out |
| Creepy and weird |
| Goosebump-making |
| Just plain weird |
| Like King novels |
| Seriously creepy |
| Shivers-inducing |
| Tremble-inducing |
| Weirdly chilling |
| Inducing shivers |
| Like King's work |
| Too coincidental |
| Chillingly weird |
| Weird and spooky |
| Like Poe's tales |
| A bit unsettling |
| Shiver-producing |
| Like Poe stories |
| Spookily strange |
| Uncannily spooky |
| Like Poe's prose |
| Out of this world |
| Goosebump-causing |
| Beyond unexpected |
| Creepy and spooky |
| Frighteningly odd |
| Giving goosebumps |
| Hardly comforting |
| Hauntingly creepy |
| Like a King story |
| Like foggy nights |
| Like many an omen |
| Like premonitions |
| Scarily unnerving |
| Scary and strange |
| TV's "___ Indiana |
| Uncannily strange |
| Fearfully strange |
| Gooseflesh-making |
| Like a King novel |
| More than strange |
| Oddly frightening |
| Chillingly spooky |
| Giving the creeps |
| Inspiring jitters |
| Inspiring shivers |
| Like poltergeists |
| Goosebump-raising |
| Causing goosebumps |
| Like ghost stories |
| Like a wolf's howl |
| An ___ resemblance |
| Chillingly uncanny |
| Creepy and ghastly |
| Disquieting, maybe |
| Far from the usual |
| Goosebump inducing |
| Goosebumps-evoking |
| Gooseflesh-raising |
| Inexplicably scary |
| Itchy-skin-causing |
| Like Gothic novels |
| Like UFO sightings |
| Raising goosebumps |
| TV town in Indiana |
| X-files descriptor |
| Chillingly strange |
| Creepy and strange |
| Like a poltergeist |
| Unnerving, perhaps |
| Disturbingly weird |
| Causing the creeps |
| Hauntingly strange |
| Weirder than weird |
| Chilling, in a way |
| Like haunted houses |
| Causing goose bumps |
| Unnatural, in a way |
| Causing chills, say |
| Chill-inducing, say |
| Chilling and creepy |
| Creeping people out |
| Evoking the shivers |
| Frightfully bizarre |
| Goose-bump-inducing |
| Hard to account for |
| Hauntingly familiar |
| How theremins sound |
| Like "Night Gallery |
| Like a creepy flick |
| Like a Koontz novel |
| Like many Poe works |
| Odd and frightening |
| Paranormal, to some |
| Unnervingly strange |
| Cause goose pimples |
| Causing butterflies |
| Inducing gooseflesh |
| Inducing the creeps |
| Not at all ordinary |
| Evoking goose bumps |
| Halloween adjective |
| Inducing goosebumps |
| Goosebumps-inducing |
| Like ghostly sounds |
| Like many Poe tales |
| Like some Poe tales |
| Raising goose bumps |
| Too weird for words |
| Causing the willies |
| Mysteriously spooky |
| Frightfully strange |
| Like a haunted house |
| Causing alarm, maybe |
| Disturbingly strange |
| Frighteningly unreal |
| Inducing goose bumps |
| Like ''The Shining'' |
| Like ''The X-Files'' |
| Like "Lost" episodes |
| Like a howl at night |
| Like a midnight howl |
| Like calm, sometimes |
| Like creepy settings |
| Like King's English? |
| Like St. Elmo's fire |
| Supernaturally weird |
| Stretched-out canal? |
| Unexplainable, maybe |
| Unsettling, in a way |
| Arousing goose bumps |
| Like Hitchcock tales |
| Like Serling stories |
| More than unsettling |
| Producing goosebumps |
| Spooky and unnatural |
| Like ghost sightings |
| Like many a Poe tale |
| Creepy and then some |
| Inducing the willies |
| Unsettlingly strange |
| Causing goose pimples |
| Frightening, in a way |
| Causing horripilation |
| Like a banshee's wail |
| Bone-chillingly weird |
| Chillingly mysterious |
| Far beyond unexpected |
| Frighteningly strange |
| Inspiring gooseflesh. |
| Like Hitchcock movies |
| Like John Saul novels |
| Like many a Poe story |
| Raising goose pimples |
| Spooky and unsettling |
| Uncomfortably strange |
| Weird and frightening |
| Able to creep you out |
| Creepily otherworldly |
| Strangely frightening |
| Like campfire stories |
| Like many Poe stories |
| Stranger than strange |
| Like Halloween sounds |
| Like many King novels |
| Weird in a creepy way |
| Causing a chill, maybe |
| Like a foggy graveyard |
| Like Saint Elmo's fire |
| Like some similarities |
| Strange and unsettling |
| Beyond what is natural |
| Like "Halloween" music |
| Like a ghost's howling |
| Like horror film music |
| Like Rod Serling tales |
| Strange and disturbing |
| Suitable for Halloween |
| Supernaturally strange |
| Weird, in a spooky way |
| Like "The Outer Limits |
| Amazingly coincidental |
| Causing heebie-jeebies |
| Hauntingly frightening |
| Like some premonitions |
| Adjective for a seance |
| Like some coincidences |
| Fit for Friday the 13th |
| Frighteningly unnatural |
| Giving goose bumps, say |
| Like a Dean Koontz book |
| Like a good ghost story |
| Like a howl at midnight |
| Like a moonlit cemetery |
| Like a theremin's sound |
| Like creaks at midnight |
| Like disembodied voices |
| Likely to creep one out |
| Spine-chillingly creepy |
| Unexplainable, in a way |
| Causing shudders, maybe |
| Creepy and supernatural |
| Like good ghost stories |
| Like "Goosebumps" tales |
| Likely to creep you out |
| Like horror movie music |
| Like much of Poe's work |
| Like "The Twilight Zone |
| Almost too coincidental |
| Evoking goose bumps, say |
| Haunted house descriptor |
| Like a Dean Koontz novel |
| Like a Koontz novel, say |
| Like a Stephen King work |
| Like howling at midnight |
| Like many campfire tales |
| Like much of King's work |
| Odd in an unsettling way |
| Like "The Shining," e.g. |
| Like a moonlit graveyard |
| Like TV's "Wayward Pines |
| Unexplainable and spooky |
| Weird, in a chilling way |
| Like Stephen King novels |
| Causing shivers, perhaps |
| Apt to cause the willies |
| '70s pulp horror magazine |
| Like a midnight graveyard |
| Like déjà vu, sometimes |
| Like many Serling stories |
| Like most Serling stories |
| Like Ouija board messages |
| Like tales of ghost ships |
| Quality of a ghost story. |
| Too weird or coincidental |
| Uncanny, as a coincidence |
| Like an empty ship at sea |
| Like Stephen King stories |
| Like "Goosebumps" stories |
| Like a Clive Barker novel |
| Uncanny, and a bit spooky |
| Like "Paranormal Activity |
| Appropriate for Halloween |
| Like a Stephen King novel |
| Like a Stephen King story |
| Causing goose flesh, maybe |
| Composer Menken and others |
| Creating a chill, in a way |
| Like many "Buffy" settings |
| Like many a campfire story |
| Like Rod Serling's stories |
| Like some campfire stories |
| Like Stephen King's novels |
| Like theremin music, often |
| More than a little strange |
| Causing goose bumps, maybe |
| Causing the heebie-jeebies |
| Like freakish coincidences |
| A little too quiet, perhaps |
| Inspiring inexplicable fear |
| Like H.P. Lovecraft stories |
| Like the 2017 film "Get Out |
| Like the film "The Babadook |
| Strangely coincidental, say |
| Like "The X-Files" episodes |
| Creepy, like a haunted house |
| Goose bumps-producing, maybe |
| Like "Dark Shadows" episodes |
| Like "Stranger Things," e.g. |
| Like a moonlit cemetery, say |
| Like H. P. Lovecraft stories |
| Like Halloween sound effects |
| Like the sound of a theremin |
| Like some Halloween costumes |
| Suggestive of the mysterious |
| Like a graveyard at midnight |
| ''___, Indiana'' (TV program) |
| Capable of causing nightmares |
| How musical saws sound, kinda |
| Like H.P. Lovecraft's stories |
| Like horror movie soundtracks |
| Like the "Blair Witch" forest |
| Like theremin noises, usually |
| Like "Tales from the Darkside |
| Like horror movie film scores |
| Like howls in a haunted house |
| Like "The Blair Witch Project |
| Like "Twilight Zone" episodes |
| Like many Rod Serling stories |
| Disturbingly coincidental, say |
| Like "The Outer Limits," often |
| Like a creaky door at midnight |
| Like footsteps in a dark alley |
| Like H. P. Lovecraft's writing |
| Like M. Night Shyamalan movies |
| Like many a Stephen King novel |
| Like many John Carpenter films |
| Like ''Night Gallery'' stories |
| Like "The Twilight Zone" music |
| Like a cemetery in midnight fog |
| Like staying in the Bates Motel |
| Fit for Friday-the-13th viewing |
| Like old graveyards at midnight |
| Capable of giving one the creeps |
| Strange, in a creepy kind of way |
| Like the remains of sunken ships |
| Astonishingly coincidental, maybe |
| Like "Thriller" and "Monster Mash |
| Like many of Dean Koontz's novels |
| Like tales that cause goose bumps |
| Reminiscent of an alien landscape |
| The Ee in HOMEeS (creepy, right?) |
| What some coincidences are deemed |
| Like "The Twilight Zone" episodes |
| Coincidental, in an unsettling way |
| Like an abandoned mansion, perhaps |
| Like many Richard Matheson stories |
| Causing the covers to be pulled up? |
| Adjective for Chas. Addams cartoons. |
| Capable of causing nightmares, maybe |
| Like a dark road on a moonless night |
| Like the old "Night Gallery" TV show |
| Like many an M. Night Shyamalan film |
| Word from Middle English for "fearful |
| Like things that go bump in the night |
| Like a wolf's howl in the dead of night |
| Perfect for telling around the campfire |
| Synonym of "mysterious" heard within it |
| Like feelings from ASMR videos, for some |
| Like photos of the Titanic before launch |
| Like an empty ship on the sea at midnight |
| Pulp horror magazine that debuted in 1966 |
| Like the vampire film "Let the Right One In |
| Like the musical intro to "The Twilight Zone |
| Like a coincidence that makes you go "Hmm ... |
| Like a portrait that seems to be watching you |
| __, Indiana": 1990s Omri Katz sci-fi TV series |
| Like a call from someone one just thought about |
| ___, Indiana" (short-lived NBC series of the '90s) |
| Like a coincidence that raises the hair on the back of your neck |
| Like having dinner with robot replicas of your parents, probably |