| In ___ way (seriously ill) |
| Creepy pencil-and-paper "game" popularized in 2015 via YouTube and Twitter (and basis of the theme answers) |
| Creepy-crawly |
| Seriously hurts |
| Don't take my insults seriously |
| You should have taken me seriously earlier ... |
| Seriously reduces |
| Is friendly (or maybe creepy) toward, silently |
| It's only ___" ("Don't take this competition so seriously"): 2 wds. |
| Seriously overcooked |
| Am I supposed to take this seriously? |
| Seriously uptight |
| Blunder seriously |
| Creepy waterway? |
| Seriously injured |
| Seriously shocked |
| Seriously verboten |
| Seriously winded |
| Seriously funny shows? |
| Seriously thoughtful or meditative |
| Salesperson who doesn't take your offer seriously? |
| Doesn't take something seriously |
| Seriously shocks |
| Creepy gaze |
| Seriously irritate, based on Verdi? |
| Become seriously entangled |
| Creepy cases |
| Cast a creepy glance |
| Seriously, man! |
| Creepy-crawlies |