Eyeofnewt

3 clues
Witches' brew ingredient
Classic brewing ingredient
Potion ingredient for a witch
Similar answers:
Aneyeoutfor
Arealeyeopener
Castaneyeover
Eyeof
Eyeofahurricane
Eyeofday
Eyeofgod
Eyeofknute
Eyeofnewt
Eyeofnewtandtoeoffrog
Eyeofnewtgingrich
Eyeofnewtsforyou
Eyeofra
Eyeofthe
Eyeofthehurricane
Eyeoftheneedle
Eyeofthestorm
Eyeofthetiger
Eyeon
Eyeontheball